Join Our Journey
Subscribe for new releases, merch drops, and stories about the recordings that were too controversial for their time.
The first year of recordings that were never supposed to be heard—now collected in one place.
In 2025, Peanut Butter Palace Records began unearthing the lost, suppressed, and "too controversial" recordings that shaped American music from the shadows. From 1930s Delta blues deemed too explicit for distribution to 1980s new wave that made college radio stations nervous, this compilation showcases the year's most significant discoveries.
Featured Artists:
This compilation represents decades of music that polite society tried to bury. Master tapes discovered in storage units, estate sales, and the dark corners of American music history—all remastered and ready for a world that still isn't quite ready.
Available formats:
Total runtime: TBD
Whether you discovered us through "He Put It In The Wrong Hole" or you've been following every release, this compilation is your complete guide to PBP Records' first year of unearthing America's most inappropriate musical treasures.
A portion of proceeds goes toward acquiring more recordings that someone tried very hard to hide.